Criminal complaint details what led to killing of teen in Two Rivers

Dominic Pilgreen (Photo courtesy Waukesha County Sheriff's Department)

CAUTION: Some viewers may find the content of this story disturbing.

TWO RIVERS, WI (WTAQ-WLUK) — Payton Vertz was tied to a tree, beaten, and then strangled to death before his clothes were burned and his body dumped into a river, according to criminal complaints released Monday.

Dominic Pilgreen, 26, and Nathan Reichard, 15, are charged with being party to first-degree intentional homicide, physical abuse of a child, hiding a corpse, theft from a corpse, and false imprisonment for the Oct. 5 death of Vertz, 16.

Reichard is scheduled to appear in court Monday. Pilgreen’s initial appearance in this case is Nov. 2.

According to the criminal complaint, Vertz was listed as a runaway on Oct. 6.

On Oct. 16, a Two Rivers high school student told police Reichard confessed to killing Vertz. That same day, another student told police that on Sept. 16, Reichard “stated that they sold someone something and if they don’t pay them back what they owe they are going to get what is coming to them.”

Police found a shoe and bicycle at Zander Park that belonged to Vertz, including clothing in a burn pit.

Also on Oct. 16, Seagull Marina reported a body washed up near the docks there.

Police interviewed Reichard, who told police he and Pilgreen got Vertz drunk with vodka so they could kill him.

Reichard told police that Pilgreen described what he planned to do to Vertz: beat him, tie him to a tree with his shoelaces, then strangle him. Reichard claimed he sat as a lookout for 90 minutes before Pilgreen returned, saying Vertz was dead.

“PILGREEN told him in detail how he killed CHILD VICTIM. PILGREEN told REICHARD that he punched CHILD VICTIM repeatedly in the face, torso and back. PILGREEN then said that CHILD VICTIM’s face was badly bruised and that he was bleeding from the head. PILGREEN also stated that after CHILD VICTIM was beaten and laying on the ground, PILGREEN took CHILD VICTIM’s shoes off of him and unlaced them and used the shoe laces to tie CHILD VICTIM to a tree. REICHARD stated that his belief for CHILD VICTIM being tied to the tree was so that he could think about why this was happening to him prior to being actually killed. PILGREEN told REICHARD that CHILD VICTIM got free from the tree resulting in PILGREEN attempting to strangle him with the shoe lace. The shoe lace did not kill him so PILGREEN took CHILD VICTIM’s belt off which he described to be brown and leather, and used that to strangle him which was successful,” the complaint states.

Reichard said that Pilgreen stole $320 off Vertz, and that he was going to dump the body in the lake or a river.

Police then interviewed Pilgreen.

Pilgreen said Vertz gave him $100 for cigarettes, vodka, and beer. Pilgreen then sent a text to Reichard, saying this would be the night they killed Vertz.

Unlike Reichard’s story, Pilgreen told police that Reichard “took a turn where he was beating CHILD VICTIM very badly and REICHARD had to restrain himself from killing CHILD VICTIM so that this could be PILGREEN’s kill,” the complaint states.

Eventually, Vertz was unconscious, but Pilgreen clamped Vertz’s belt around his neck for 20 minutes to make sure he was dead.

Pilgreen said he used a wagon to dispose of Vertz’s body. Police later found the wagon, and the belt.

A second interview with police took place, with Pilgreen offering more explanation on why it happened.

“PILGREEN stated that he despised CHILD VICTIM for what he did but “Kesley” only saw that as a reason to come out, like used that as an excuse to kill. It should be noted that PILGREEN said “Kesley” is a personality of his. He stated that Kesley has thought about killing someone for years. He stated this was his first kill but he has tortured and gotten into physical altercations,” the complaint states.

Police talked to Reichard again, who then admitted more active participation.

“REICHARD stated the first thing that happened was that he hit CHILD VICTIM with a stick and then PILGREEN held CHILD VICTIM up against a tree and they started punching him in the gut and PILGREEN kneed him in the side. REICHARD describes having more second thoughts but they were already in it and couldn’t stop,” the complaint states.

Reichard also helped tie Vertz to a tree, before again kneeing and punching him.

“They continued to tell him to admit and CHILD VICTIM kept questioning why this was happening to him. This was making them both “extra pissed because of constant repeating,” the complaint states.

As did Pilgreen, Reichard claimed a second persona.

“REICHARD stated that it was almost 1 am and he was also fighting Hallow and it then became very dangerous for CHILD VICTIM because Hallow came out. Hallow is REICHARD’s violent personality that he claims to have,” the complaint states.

An autopsy showed Vertz suffered brain injuries, multiple contusions and abrasions around the neck, and multiple bruises around his body, the complaint states.